Top Five Books of 2008

There’s still a few books I hope to get through before award nomination time (notably The Quiet War and Half a Crown), but this is my list of the top five of books I read in 2008 which were actually published in 2008.

1. The Gone-Away World, Nick Harkaway
It’s not the most polished novel I read this year, or the most tightly plotted, but it was the most exuberant, enthralling, joyous novel I read this year. Niall said the “meandering, tangential narrative is apparently almost Stephensonian in its excess”, and I loved nearly every wandering digression it takes. Some chapters are more engrossing than others, and the ending feels a little anti-climatic, but the main reason why this and not Anathem is sitting atop my list is that unlike Jonathan’s experience, it pulled me in emotionally and I didn’t realise it until one twisty chapter two-thirds of the way through.

2. Anathem, Neal Stephenson
I covered it in more detail here, but I liked the way that Stephenson has taken his love of meandering digression and found a way to work it into a science fiction plot. Much like Cryptonomicon the female characters are not much cop (although the unreliable narrator can be blamed for some of that), and the first hundred pages are a hard slog, but once it all clicks into place it is magical.

3. The Steel Remains, Richard Morgan
Richard Morgan takes his love for writing (and subverting) extremely manly novels into the fantasy genre, and it’s not surprising that what we get is a brutal, bloody, swear-filled, angry novel with lots of fucking. when I read I hadn’t read any Moorcock, and now I’ve read a little Elric I can see the debt it owes, but it feels like a modern take on the idea. The three characters are a little unbalnaced, and I would have liked to see more of Archeth, but I enjoyed it a hell of a lot, especially the take on homosexuality.

4. Song of Time, Ian R MacLeod
It doesn’t have the exuberance of the previous three books, nor is it as filled with wonderful ideas, but Song of Time has its own charm. The alternating narrative, between an old woman looking back on her life and the experiences she had, is elegantly written, and reminded me of McAuley’s Fairyland in the descriptions of a near-future Europe in turmoil. I was impressed with the ending, which manages to pull off something which would in less capable hands feel like an unsatisfying revelation.

5. Matter, Iain M Banks
I’ll be honest – I read this book very early in the year, and I can’t remember so much of the detail. But I remember thinking it was a fine return to the Culture, and as you may have guessed from my top three books of the year I am a sucker for anything which has enthusiasm and humour and great big SF ideas, and Matter has all three. I’m pretty sure that you could have cut 200 pages or so without problem, but I enjoyed reading them anyway.

8 Responses to “Top Five Books of 2008”

  1. Jonathan M Says:

    Interesting list Liz. I’m glad to see Gone Away World in there as while I think the ending is something of a calamity, I really think that Harkaway has the potential to go on to bigger and better things. However, I don’t get the impression that the book set the world alight despite the forceful PR shove he got.

    Having said that I found the Steel Remains to be close to unreadable and Matter to be really very disappointing indeed.

  2. Nick H. Says:

    The Gone-Away World is probably the book I most regret not having been able to read this year. And, echoing Mr M. above, I have noticed it appears to be a bit of a tough sell to people. Damn their eyes.

  3. gav (nextread.co.uk) Says:

    Liz,

    I’ve not read any of these.

    New Years resolution – Read Longer Books! Or at least pick up digital editions so that Anathem doesn’t look sooo scary!

  4. The Great Geek Manual » Geek Media Round-Up: January 1, 2009 Says:

    […] Lists of the Best Books of 2008 from: Adventures in Reading, Amazon.com, BookGasm, The Detroit Examiner, Fantasy Hotlist, io9, Publisher’s Weekly, Stephen King, Torque Control, […]

  5. The Best of 2008, Redux « Torque Control Says:

    […] Top Five Books of 2008 […]

  6. james Says:

    I haven’t read enough boks published in 2008, and need to find flood fast to read and nominate it for the BSFA. I am so far not finding many covers either, and specifically spent half an hour looking at book covers in waterstoes, I was gutted that the peace and war by Dominic Harman is not valid, as its well old.

    J

  7. Homo Sum » Blog Archive » Closing the book-related tabs Says:

    […] that I’ve read and enjoyed 4 of the 5 books on this particular best of 2008 list, I probably have a very good motivation to go seek out The Gone-Away World by Nick […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: