I Declare This Focus Week Open

If I were a proper blogger, I would no doubt have a banner of some kind with which to preface this post. As it is, you’ll have to make do with text: welcome to the start of a week of discussion of sf by women.

A quick review of how this came about is in order. Back in October, Tricia Sullivan gave an interview in which, among other things, she discussed the fact that the proportion of Arthur C Clarke Awards going to women has nose-dived in the last ten years — one winner between 2001 and 2010, compared to five between 1991 and 2000. I spun this off into a discussion here, which eventually ranged far and wide over possible causes and effects.

My follow-up to the discussion has, so far, had two parts. First, I’ve been reading sf by women, most of it recent, to provide material for discussion this week. And second, of course, I’ve been running a poll to determine what people collectively think are the best science fiction novels by women published between 2001 and 2010, as a starting point to address the more rapid canonisation of works by men, via representation on award ballots and in promotions such as the Gollancz Future Classics.

So another thing I’ll be doing this week is posting the top ten, and a couple of other cuts of the data. Some notes on the limitations and quality of the dataset are in order first, however.

In total, 101 people nominated 205 novels by 133 writers: so not an enormous voting population, but a pretty healthy one, and one that looks like it’s acheived quite healthy coverage of the field. About 45% of voters were men, compared to 40% women and 15% unknown; about 40% of voters were British, compared to 15% American, 10% from the rest of the world, and 35% unknown. (I suspect the unknowns were disproportionately American, based on voting patterns and the fact that I’m more likely to already know British readers, so I don’t think the sample is quite as British-biased as it looks.) The median number of nominations was 10, and the mean was 6, and indeed a fair number of people noted that they hadn’t read as widely as they might, and wondered if this might bias the poll results. For that reason, I would continue to direct your attention to the individual lists that have been posted over the past two months, whose idiosyncracies are a necessary counterpart to the lists I’m going to post here this week. I’ll be linking to recent discussions of sf by women throughout the week, so if anyone else wants to post their own top ten in the next few days, please do, and I’ll round them all up on Friday.

And with all that said: let the discussion commence.

About these ads
Posted in SF. Tags: , . 19 Comments »

19 Responses to “I Declare This Focus Week Open”

  1. iansales Says:

    I’m going to seriously try and get my piece on Gwyneth Jones’ Bold as Love Cycle finished and posted on my blog this week. I’ve yet to read the fifth book in L Timmel Duchamp’s Marq’ssan Cycle, so that’ll probably have to wait until the new year.

  2. Women and the Clarke II | Solar Bridge Says:

    [...] overall, I prefer the first choice, but The New Moon’s Arms is still rather good (funny). There’s a post today and Torque Control will be covering this over the next [...]

  3. Niall Says:

    Ian: excellent! I look forward to reading it.

  4. arkessian Says:

    Out of pure curiosity, how have you determined where a response came from? I’d be interested to see an analysis of voting patterns vs. origin (not that you haven’t got enough to do, of course!)

  5. Niall Says:

    Nothing clever, I’m afraid — simply that I know which country a lot of the people who nominated are from.

  6. Future Classics: #10 « Torque Control Says:

    [...] I Declare This Focus Week Open [...]

  7. Future Classics: #9 « Torque Control Says:

    [...] I Declare This Focus Week Open [...]

  8. Future Classics: #8 « Torque Control Says:

    [...] I Declare This Focus Week Open [...]

  9. Galactic Suburbia 22 « Randomly Yours, Alex Says:

    [...] Control’s Week of Women & SF (also [...]

  10. REVIEW – Servant of the Underworld (2010) by Aliette de Bodard « Ruthless Culture Says:

    [...] ZONE have my small contribution to Niall Harrison‘s attempt to raise the profile of the current crop of female genre [...]

  11. Future Classics: #7 « Torque Control Says:

    [...] calculated from 101 responses to a poll run during October, November and December [...]

  12. Future Classics: #5 « Torque Control Says:

    [...] calculated from 101 responses to a poll run during October, November and December [...]

  13. Future Classics: #4 « Torque Control Says:

    [...] calculated from 101 responses to a poll run during October, November and December [...]

  14. Future Classics: #3 « Torque Control Says:

    [...] calculated from 101 responses to a poll run during October, November and December [...]

  15. Top Ten Writers « Torque Control Says:

    [...] calculated from 101 responses to a poll run during October, November and December [...]

  16. Future Classics: #1 « Torque Control Says:

    [...] calculated from 101 responses to a poll run during October, November and December [...]

  17. Yet More Top Tens « Torque Control Says:

    [...] calculated from 101 responses to a poll run during October, November and December [...]

  18. Social Justice Saturday: But Why Aren’t Men Writing Urban Fantasy? « Tui Talk Says:

    [...] in many places that has, extraordinarily, been really very thoughtful. Torque is now having a focus week on women SF writers of the last decade and if you read blogs about science fiction at all [...]

  19. Reading Future Classics by Women « Torque Control Says:

    [...] to reading books on import instead of waiting for the possibility of local publication. Further, a major proportion of the poll participants were based outside of the UK, and so this country’s publication schedule does not necessarily affect the local [...]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 90 other followers

%d bloggers like this: